7 Bakeries to Order Your Thanksgiving Pie From

From traditional pumpkin to non-traditional candy bar variations, these local bakeries have all your Thanksgiving pie needs covered.

Photo courtesy of Blackbirds and Twenty.

When I think Thanksgiving, I’m really thinking dessert. Bundled up, sitting around a firepit with good friends and family, a warm cup of coffee and a slice of pie within reach. It’s the magical conclusion to a good holiday gathering, but it’s one that requires some advance preparation.

With Thanksgiving only a few weeks away, now’s the time to order your Thanksgiving pies. From traditional pumpkin to decadent chocolate to gluten-free these seven New York City bakeries have your needs covered. Go ahead and have a slice or two:

Photo courtesy of Bubby’s.

Bubby’s, Tribeca + Highline
With the ability to have one of Bubby’s pies shipped right to your door there’s no excuse to not be biting into a buttery, flakey, crust on Thanksgiving day. Order by November 17, for delivery on November 22, local pick-ups can placed up to November 19. Pies start at $40.

Butter & Scotch, Crown Heights
This Thanksgiving, Brooklyn’s dessert and cocktail bar, Butter & Scotch is dishing up classics such as Apple, Whiskey Peanut Butter Apple, Pumpkin Sweet Potato and local favorites including Bourbon Ginger Pecan, S’mores, and Key Lime. Pre-order your pies online for pick-up the Monday-Wednesday before Thanksgiving. Pies start at $40.

Daly Pie, Prospect Heights
Order one of the whimsical pies Daly Pie like Chocolate Guinness and Caramel Coconut Icebox and no will remember if you burn the casserole. Pies start at $35 and orders must be placed by Sunday, November 19.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, Gowanus
With creative twists on classics Four & Twenty Blackbirds will have even non-pie-lovers swooning. Choose from Salted Honey, Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan, Brown Butter Pumpkin and Salted Caramel Apple. Pies start at $42.

Photo by Scott Gordon Bleicher

Petee’s Pie Company, Lower East Side
On the Lower East Side, Petee’s Pie Company is a one stop shop for pie lovers, with options that include traditional pumpkin, gluten-free and more. Order online by Sunday, November 19 for delivery or pick-up in person the week of Thanksgiving. Pies start at $30.

Read More: The Long-Forgotten New York Pie That Was “The Cronut of 1946”

Pies n’ Thighs, Williamsburg + Lower East Side
Take advantage of Pies n’ Thighs options which include the fruit sour cherry and pear crumble to the decadent bourbon pecan to the classic pumpkin. Pies start at $30 and orders must be placed by Sunday, November 19.

Photo courtesy of Gramercy Tavern

Gramercy Tavern, Flatiron
Upgrade the classic Thanksgiving desserts with a pie from Gramercy Tavern. Choose from Chocolate Bourbon Pecan or Spiced Marshmallow Pumpkin pie. Order online to pick-up on November 21 and 22. Pies start at $50.

SaveSave

Newsletter

Categories

Tags

Bridget is the digital strategy editor for Edible Manhattan, Edible Brooklyn, Edible Long Island and Edible East End.